Loading the supporter pulse…
Weekly Fan Mood Report
Manchester United suffers massive collapse to headline the latest Overreaction Index
Sep 14, 2026 - Sep 20, 2026
Top 5 mood swings
Sep 14, 2026 - Sep 20, 2026
Week-on-week change in fan sentiment across every club the report covers.
- 1
Premier Leaguenow 31↘ -39 change this week - 2
Major League Soccernow 77↗ +35 change this week - 3
Ligue 1now 81↗ +32 change this week - 4
Süper Lignow 76↗ +29 change this week - 5
Premier Leaguenow 70↗ +28 change this week
By Sam Hannan
Manchester United suffers massive collapse to headline the latest Overreaction Index
This week exposed a stark split between global stability and individual club volatility, as Nashville SC surged while Manchester United suffered a staggering collapse. Manchester United saw the week's sharpest decline with a weekly change of -39, while the global average slipped just -0.38 points. Across multiple leagues, supporter perception drifted away from baseline performances to create a clear results mismatch.
Narrative Divergence
Trabzonspor recorded a massive narrative disconnect of +34.50, where fan mood ran far ahead of baseline performance expectations. Nottingham Forest and Arsenal sat on the opposite end, recording narrative gaps of -31.20 and -28.50 respectively as supporter sentiment dropped well below baseline metrics.
Biggest Mood Swings
Manchester United plummeted
Sentiment Leaders and Laggards
Weekly close sentiment score distribution.
Biggest Mood Swings
The largest changes in fan mood since last week.
League Comparison
Sentiment scores and weekly changes are shown on separate scales for readability.
| League | Average sentiment | Average change |
|---|---|---|
 Serie A | 61.2 | +3.59 |
 Premier League | 60.8 | +1.35 |
 Serie A | 60.5 | +2.64 |
 Ligue 1 | 59.6 | -3.25 |
 Super League 1 | 58.0 | +1.5 |
 Eredivisie | 57.6 | -2.07 |
 Primeira Liga | 57.4 | +1.57 |
 Major League Soccer | 57.0 | -1.64 |
Highlight Team
Manchester UnitedManchester United produced the week's strongest emotional reaction (-39) with a 31-point internal swing. On-pitch baseline outperformed fan reaction, signaling a confidence lag.
Top 5 Happiest Fanbases
| Team | Score | Weekly change | Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
 Nashville SC | 86 | +15 | Week close 86 with +15 change. |
 Como | 85 | -1 | Week close 85 with -1 change. |
 Sunderland | 83 | +25 | Week close 83 with +25 change. |
 New England Revolution | 83 | +6 | Week close 83 with +6 change. |
 Real Betis | 82 | +11 | Week close 82 with +11 change. |
Bottom 5 Fanbases
| Team | Score | Weekly change | Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
 Borussia Mönchengladbach | 19 | -8 | Week close 19 with -8 change. |
 PEC Zwolle | 24 | -23 | Week close 24 with -23 change. |
 Real Salt Lake | 26 | -3 | Week close 26 with -3 change. |
 Al-Nassr | 27 | -26 | Week close 27 with -26 change. |
 Valencia | 28 | -11 | Week close 28 with -11 change. |
Biggest Mood Swings
| Team | Weekly change | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Manchester United | -39 | Moved -39 this week with 31 point internal swing. |
| Columbus Crew | +35 | Moved +35 this week with 37 point internal swing. |
| Lille | +32 | Moved +32 this week with 31 point internal swing. |
Narrative vs Results
| Team | Mood vs results | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Trabzonspor | 34.5 | Narrative proxy divergence measured at +34.50. |
 Nottingham Forest | -31.2 | Narrative proxy divergence measured at -31.20. |
 Arsenal | -28.5 | Narrative proxy divergence measured at -28.50. |